N
No Gods, No Masters
Guest
Question for those who accept evolution as fact, but believe in an eternal soul:
When in our evolution was the soul introduced? Since you accept evolution, you know that when we analyze the fossil record, our naming system is arbitrary, in that we put species with similar traits together. The dividing line between many hominid species is just for ease of classifying (this classification system is justified, but still arbitrary). There isn't a moment in a species' evolution where it's species X, then it has a baby, then the baby is species Y.
If we could watch the evolution of Homo sapiens, we'd notice that each child, of one of our ancestors, looks exactly like its parent, a little less so than it's great-grandparents, etc. Only over a macro, lengthy bit of time would we notice a general shift in the appearance of the species.
The choice to call one fossil Homo sapiens and call another fossil species Z is pure choice, and not how evolution actually occurs
If this makes sense, and I hope it does, when in our evolution was the soul introduced, knowing the fact that our ancestors were not Homo sapien (humans), but a different species altogether (as we'd classify today)?
When in our evolution was the soul introduced? Since you accept evolution, you know that when we analyze the fossil record, our naming system is arbitrary, in that we put species with similar traits together. The dividing line between many hominid species is just for ease of classifying (this classification system is justified, but still arbitrary). There isn't a moment in a species' evolution where it's species X, then it has a baby, then the baby is species Y.
If we could watch the evolution of Homo sapiens, we'd notice that each child, of one of our ancestors, looks exactly like its parent, a little less so than it's great-grandparents, etc. Only over a macro, lengthy bit of time would we notice a general shift in the appearance of the species.
The choice to call one fossil Homo sapiens and call another fossil species Z is pure choice, and not how evolution actually occurs
If this makes sense, and I hope it does, when in our evolution was the soul introduced, knowing the fact that our ancestors were not Homo sapien (humans), but a different species altogether (as we'd classify today)?